Global Economic Dynamics

China’s Belt and Road: Shifting Trade to Asia?

By Edward Logan

September 21st, 2017


At a May 2017 forum in Beijing, China’s President Xi Jinping expounded on the evolving opportunities for China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)1 to connect with the development strategies of various other countries, specifically naming neighbors Russia, Kazakhstan, Vietnam, Laos, and Myanmar.

Far from just an economic strategy, BRI lays the foundation for far more extensive political and geo-strategic interaction between Eurasian countries than did the similarly ambitious U.S.-centric Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) and Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP).

China is using BRI to solidify political relationships with neighbors like Brunei. Brunei’s presence in the BRI would give China more influence in ASEAN. Another ally in the region could give China more leverage in South China Sea discussions.2

The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor branch of the BRI would be comparable to the Marshall Plan, completely transforming the Pakistani economy and leaving the country geo-strategically intertwined with China well into the foreseeable future.3

Rewriting the rules

A less discussed aspect of BRI is its potential to reshape the global financial system. Some argue that the Chinese-led Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) exists to supplant the existing Bretton Woods system. Valid or not, a successful BRI will ultimately raise the profile of Chinese banks and give them greater influence on how business is done globally.

Since 2010, China has increased its exports substantially to areas to its south and southwest, while trade with countries to its north and northwest like Russia and Kazakhstan has stagnated (Map).

Map: BRI could revitalize trade with areas west of China and bolster trade in the south

BRI could revitalize trade with areas west of China and bolster trade in the south

BRI would create flourishing trade relationships with all these partners, potentially with strings attached, however. Countries like Vietnam and South Korea would prefer to strategically reduce their heavy reliance on the Chinese economy, the latter having recently suffered under Chinese sanctions following the deployment of the THAAD missile system.

With China’s promise of at least a trillion dollars in investment, passing up this opportunity to more closely enter China’s sphere of influence is itself economically risky. Can Vietnam afford to sit out of BRI while its neighbors reap massive benefits from trade and investment from China?

European leaders must ask themselves similar questions. While TTIP is in a comatose state, the EU could instead look east to grow its trade. The tentative plan is for BRI’s land and maritime routes to end in Rotterdam and Venice, respectively, and then link together.

Given recent U.S. rhetoric on trade along with the failures of TPP and TTIP, countries everywhere may have to consider the newer, less certain future of BRI as an alternative. This could mean concessions in areas like markets rules and international standards. As BRI is an entire framework rather than a few isolated projects, it could potentially rewrite those rules.

 


1 For an explanation and graphic representation of China’s Belt and Road Initiative, see “’New Silk Road’ and China’s hegemonic ambition.” Deutsche Welle, May 15, 2017.

2China, Brunei to Boost Ties.” XinhuaNet, Xinhua News Agency, September 13, 2017.

3 Curran, Enda. “China’s Marshall Plan.” Bloomberg.com, Bloomberg L. P., August 7, 2016.

 

Public Dissatisfaction Points to a Toss-Up in 2022

As the 2022 midterm election approaches, the media increasingly treats likely outcomes as a horse race.  Most recently, Sara Palin’s loss to Mary Peltola was taken as a signal that

Inflation Policy: You Can’t Get There From Here!

Inflation Policy: You Can’t Get There From Here!

While the Fed has ostensibly dropped the term “transitory” from its public statements, its latest inflation projections show it is clinging to the notion privately. (more…)

Energy Equity in the Pursuit of Decarbonization

Energy Equity in the Pursuit of Decarbonization

Mark Finley is the fellow in energy and global oil at Rice University's Baker Institute. He has 35 years of experience working at the intersections of energy, economics and public

What Happened to the Labor Market?

What Happened to the Labor Market?

The following article is an excerpt from our most recent GFG Client Briefing, U.S. Employment Futures and Fed Policy. The pandemic shock and ensuing recovery induced seismic shifts in the

The COVID Containment Challenge

The COVID Containment Challenge

Summer has passed.  Fall is here and so is the annual flu season.  New cases of COVID-19 are running at about 45,000 a day in the United States and 300,000

GFG U.S. Pandemic Monitor

Our COVID-19 Monitor features automatic daily updates and charts highlighting important national and state trends.  These trends include total cases, new cases, testing, and percent positives.  Given recent increases in

Passive Investing Concentrates and Increases Stock Market Risk

Passive Investing Concentrates and Increases Stock Market Risk

The S&P 500 is down 12 percent in the past seven trading days ending February 27th. This is the largest concentrated decline since the financial crisis. (more…)

Approaches to Digital Taxation Splinter

Approaches to Digital Taxation Splinter

The following article is an excerpt from our fall Client Report, Digitalization: The New Tax Frontier. A foundational challenge for digital taxation is that most digital activity is attached to

Lord John Browne

Engineering Future Progress: An Interview with Lord John Browne

Lord John Browne was CEO of BP from 1995 to 2007. Under his leadership, the company grew to become the world’s first “supermajor” and took steps to acknowledge and address

Michael A. Brown

The Military Technology Challenge: An Interview with Michael Brown

Michael Brown is the Director of the Defense Innovation Unit (DIU) at the U.S. Department of Defense. With offices in Silicon Valley, Boston, Austin and at the Pentagon, DIU’s mission

U.S. Headed Toward Manufacturing Downturn, Joining Global Trend

U.S. Headed Toward Manufacturing Downturn, Joining Global Trend

Thoughts shared as we prepare our next Global Outlook report highlight a broad-based decline in manufacturing in the United States concurrent with slowdowns in most of the world’s major manufacturing

Wealth Inequality Is Not Income Inequality

Wealth Inequality Is Not Income Inequality

To date, the debate over inequality has concentrated on income inequality and solutions such as increasing the marginal tax rates for high-income individuals or increasing taxes on estates at death.

 
close

CLIENT LOGIN

Login in below to access content exclusive to clients of The GailFosler Group.

Not a client yet? For more information on the benefits of becoming a client, please contact us.